Simulations of complex systems: New languages for re-thinking the future and the disciplines

Choice of the scientific topics addressed in the module

The module is focused on computational simulations. These advanced tools that nowadays characterize the methods of research and innovation are framed within the wider paradigm change brought by the data revolution and data-intensive methodologies that invest not only the STEM disciplines but also the social sciences and the arts. In particular, the module is focused on agent-based simulations as methods that can be used to model complex systems that consist of many individual components that interact among each other and with the environment. Agent-based simulations are analysed from a conceptual and computational point of view for their key role of embedding mechanisms of interaction, properties of the agents and emerging features of the systems, and for their use to elaborate possible future scenarios. By exploiting analogical reasoning, the students are guided to recognize that simulations originally formulated to model predator-prey interactions or the behavior of magnetic materials can be applied to model societal situations like the behavior of economic markets and opinion dynamics.

Relationship with FEDORA main themes

The module on computational simulations embeds mainly the FEDORA's themes of interdisciplinarity and futures. Indeed, the object of computational simulation lies at the interface between physical modelling, mathematical formalization, and computational implementation but also social sciences; hence, it can be characterized as an interdisciplinary "boundary" object. Moreover, simulations have a future-oriented character since they allow to perform experiments in a virtual laboratory in which many possible scenarios of future evolution of many types of systems can be obtained; the future-oriented character of simulations is mirrored in a series of activities of scenarios' construction based on simulaitons that aims at enhancing students' immagination toward the future through science education.

Learning outcomes

  • learning the basic concepts of complex systems and computational simulations;
  • exploring the applications of simulations in STEM and other areas of knowledge;
  • understanding the conceptual and epistemological difference between equation-based and agent-based modelling;
  • interpreting simple agent-based models, their assumptions, the mechanisms they embed, the properties of the agents, the parameters that can be changed, the scenarios that can be obtained;
  • being able to extend a simple model to a different application context through the exploitation of conceptual analogies, also pointing out limitations and potentials of the analogy;
  • learning basic concepts of futures studies (scenarios, probable/possible/desirable futures, back-casting) and experiencing how simulations can be the basis through which implementing these concepts;
  • discussing pressing societal issues, values and desires based on the discussion of a computational artifact.

Brief overview over the module's structure

The module consists of about 20 hours, articulated in different types of activities. Since the beginning, students are introduced to the main pillars of the module: interdisciplinarity and future, both reflecting on the complex intertwining between science and society. The module starts with an overview lecture on the computational science in the era of big data. Then, activities are conducted to make students experience the variety of researches that can be carried out based on simulations: in our implementation, presentations were delivered by experts or researchers who use simulations for their studies in the field of climatology, infectivology, astrophysics, particle physics and also arts and creativity. Special time is then dedicated to explore interactively with students some agent-based simulations in Netlogo, by pointing out the features of the models they embed (from a physical, mathematical and computational perspectives) and the scenarios they produce. To bridge the scientific models to societal applications, an activity is carried out to make students develop analogies between the previously encountered simulations and real societal issues. After a presentation on the main concepts and vocabulary of futures studies, the last activity of the module asks the students to work in group to work on a simulation to elaborate possible and desirable future scenarios for the school of the future and to outline possible actions to be undertaken to achieve the preferred one.

Papers and resources to deepen the topic

Barelli, E. (2022). Imagining the school of the future through computational simulations: Scenarios’ sustainability and agency as keywords. Frontiers in Education, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2022.897582
Barelli, E., & Levrini, O. (2022). Computational simulations at the interface of physics and society: a teaching-learning module for high school students. Il Nuovo Cimento C, 45(6). doi:10.1393/ncc/i2022-22213-6
Barelli, E., & Levrini, O. (2022). Navigating micro and macro levels of agent-based simulations to build analogies with real-world issues. In G.S. Carvalho, A.S. Afonso & Z. Anastácio (Eds.), Fostering scientific citizenship in an uncertain world (Proceedings of ESERA 2021), Part 8 (co-ed. Antti Laherto and Eliza Rybska), (pp.631-640). Braga: CIEC, University of Minho. ISBN 978-972-8952-82-2.
Title of the Activity
Title of the resource
Type of the resource
Link
Introduction to the course
Introduction to the course
teaching resource
Writing and reflecting on the future
My 2040... an essay
worksheet
Writing and reflecting on the future
Sensemaker questionnaire
data collection tool
Getting to know the role of simulations in the sciences
Computational science in the big data era
teaching resource
Simulations and arts
teaching resource
Simulations and cosmology
teaching resource
Simulations and meteorology
teaching resource
Simulations and infectivology
teaching resource
Simulations and accelerators
teaching resource
Simulations and particle physics
teaching resource
Exploring and analysing simple examples of agent-based simulations
Agent-based simulations: let's get to know them better!
worksheet
Tasks for the analysis of the simulations
teaching resource
Developing analogies between simple agent-based models and real-life issues
From models to problems
teaching resource
Tasks for the development of the analogy
worksheet
Future-oriented activity: imagining the school of the future
Introduction to the relation between simulations and futures
teaching resource
Tasks for the future-oriented activity
worksheet
Wrapping-up and reflecting on the changes in future's perception
Final questionnaire on the changes of future described in the essay
worksheet
Sensemaker questionnaire
data collection tool
FEDORA, Future-oriented Science Education to enhance Responsibility and Engagement in the society of acceleration and uncertainty, is a 3-year EU-funded project. It started in September 2020 and will deploy its activities until August 2023. It gathers 6 partner institutions from 5 European countries.
FEDORA has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under Grant Agreement no. 872841
crossmenuchevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram